top of page
  • Writer's pictureDr. Jason Regis

The Pitfalls of Overdoing Exercise in New Year's Resolutions: Striking a Balance for Long-Term Health

Updated: Feb 4

calendar book on desk - heading says goals

As the calendar turns and the New Year begins, a lot of us embark on a journey to improve our health and fitness. New Year's resolutions often involve adopting a more active lifestyle, with exercise taking center stage. While the enthusiasm to kickstart a fitness routine is commendable, it's crucial to strike a balance and avoid the common pitfall of overdoing it.

The Allure of New Year's Resolutions:

Every January, we see more gym memberships, more people out walking and running, and home exercise equipment sales skyrocket. The New Year is a time for a fresh start after falling off during the holiday season, offering the perfect opportunity to set ambitious health and fitness goals. However, the excitement of the new beginning can sometimes lead individuals to set unrealistic expectations and push themselves too hard.

The Dangers of Overtraining

First of all, most of us are not 18 anymore, meaning that we cannot and SHOULD not do what we used to do.  And sometimes, we just do too much too soon.  You’ve heard the saying “Rome wasn’t built in a day.”  Well, those pounds you put on or those unwanted habits don’t go away in a day either.  Overdoing exercise, also known as overtraining, can have detrimental effects on both physical and mental well-being. Some of the common pitfalls associated with excessive exercise include:

1.    Increased Risk of Injury: Pushing the body beyond its limits increases the risk of injuries such as strains, sprains, and stress fractures. Overuse injuries can sideline individuals for weeks or even months, hindering their progress and motivation.

2.    Burnout and Mental Exhaustion: Excessive exercise can lead to burnout and mental fatigue. The initial excitement of the New Year's resolution may fade as individuals find themselves exhausted, demotivated, and struggling to maintain consistency.

3.    Compromised Immune Function: Intense and prolonged exercise without adequate rest can compromise the immune system, making individuals more susceptible to illnesses. This can undermine the overall goal of improving health.

4.    Negative Impact on Sleep: Rigorous exercise close to bedtime may disrupt sleep patterns, leading to insomnia and overall sleep deprivation. Quality sleep is essential for recovery and overall well-being.

Striking a Balance

To maximize the benefits of a New Year's fitness resolution without falling into the trap of overtraining, individuals should consider the following tips:

1.   Set Realistic Goals: Instead of aiming for drastic changes, set realistic and achievable goals. Gradual progress is more sustainable and less likely to result in burnout.  Set an attainable goal of 1-2 times per week instead of 5-7 days a week and then build on your success.


2.    Incorporate Rest Days: Rest days are essential for recovery. Incorporate scheduled rest days into your fitness routine to allow your body to recover and reduce the risk of overuse injuries.  Rest and stretching are just as important as working out!



3.    Listen to Your Body: Pay attention to signals from your body. If you experience persistent fatigue, soreness, or pain, it's crucial to adjust your exercise routine and give your body the rest it needs.  I like to say it’s a matter of Risk vs. Reward.  Is it worth the risk of injury if you are sidelined and can’t work out for a few weeks?  Losing your progress is not worth the extra 5 minutes of pain on the treadmill or reps of a weight exercise.


4.    Diversify Your Routine: Avoid focusing exclusively on one type of exercise. Incorporate a variety of activities to engage different muscle groups and reduce the risk of overuse injuries.  Studies have shown that performing the same type of exercise leads to injury because of only developing those specific muscle groups.

5.    Prioritize Adequate Sleep: Ensure you get enough quality sleep, as it plays a crucial role in recovery and overall well-being. Establish a consistent sleep routine and avoid intense exercise close to bedtime.

Embarking on a fitness journey as part of a New Year's resolution is great.  However, it's essential to approach exercise with a balanced mindset, avoiding the temptation to overdo it. By setting realistic goals, incorporating rest days, and listening to your body, you can achieve sustainable progress and make long-term improvements to your health and fitness. Remember, the key to success lies in finding the right balance that works for your individual needs and capabilities.

9 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page